• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Wish Steakhouse: Premier Steakhouse Dining in Weston, WI with Exceptional Steaks & Decadent Desserts

Wish Steakhouse in Weston, WI, is a gem for steak lovers seeking quality and ambiance. Known for perfectly cooked steaks like the melt-in-your-mouth filet mignon and marbled ribeye, it also offers standout dishes such as ribs, scallops, and panko-crusted walleye with asparagus. The desserts—key lime pie, chocolate cake, and red velvet—are crafted with finesse, delivering memorable sweetness. The attentive, friendly staff and inviting atmosphere elevate every visit, making it ideal for celebrations or intimate dinners. While prices lean upscale, the generous portions and flawless flavors justify the experience. Wish Steakhouse truly blends fine dining with heartfelt hospitality.

Wish Steakhouse at a glance

  • Address 5006 E Jelinek Ave, Weston, WI 54476, United States
  • Phone +1 715-298-2903
  • Restaurant type Steak house .
  • Popular for Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Wish Steakhouse: Reviews & Ratings

Gary Smith
5

It's hard to even know where to start. The whole evening was amazing. We were early for our reservation and to our surprise they seated us immediately. Every course came out quickly and perfectly timed. We never waited which was awesome. The pork belly is divine. The best pork belly I think I've ever had. The pickles with it were okay,but I would have been just happy with the plain pork belly. It was so good. Every course was more perfect than the last. My only complaint of the whole evening in fact was that my steak was extremely salty. I couldn't finish an otherwise absolutely perfect steak,but the rest of the food was perfectly seasoned. Maybe the chef dropped the salt shaker or something because they sure knocked everything else out of the park. They must have a very talented pastry chef because the deserts were just amazing. The key lime pie is sweet and tangy and the chocolate cake is absolute perfection. It was better than my grandma made(sorry grandma)and that's a difficult achievement. Service was excellent and our waitress knew just when to pop in. The restaurant was nice and clean and the ambiance was great. Overall it was a wonderful experience. We will definitely be back for more date nights in the future! 10 out of 10.

Kristee Morrell
5

Yesterday, my husband made my 40th birthday one to remember with the help from the staff at Wish Steakhouse. They had our table waiting with flowers he had ordered, a beautiful sign, and the table was candle lit. Our server Beca went above and beyond, helping in every way possible. She even sang Happy Birthday to me with my husband. If ever in the area and want a perfect steak, one that melts in your mouth, with a perfectly char on the outside, this is it. Not to mention the ambiance and attention to detail from every aspect and every employee. If interested in a nice dinner, company event, or celebrating a milestone, this is a wonderful place to cherish that memory.

Emily Seehafer
5

This place does not get the recognition it deserves. I’ve been here maybe 4 times and each visit is excellent. They are a true steakhouse with a fine selection of high quality steaks. The filet mignon ties for the best steak I’ve ever had. We celebrated our anniversary here this past week and enjoyed all of the dishes and drinks. If you want a high end steakhouse for an honestly reasonable price, Wish is a great place. Also, look at the cake. Slices the size of my head and truly divine Raspberry Grapefruit Pilsner from Fifth Ward House margarita (not pictured, Tyler loved) Smoked salmon dip appetizer House salad (French dressing is excellent) Shrimp Caesar salad Ribeye with mashed potatoes Chocolate layer cake Red velvet cheesecake

Jennifer Stegall
5

Most amazing food ever! Little pricey but so worth it. I will definitely go back! My waiter/bartender was the best. You know he enjoys his job. He just bragged constantly about the owner the other staff etc.... He made the experience even better.

ROGDragonicKing
5

The experience here is perfect. The staff are very friendly, respectful and professional. The food is also perfect here. I have been here twice and both times have been nothing but perfect. Our drinks were always full as well. The servers do a fantastic job here. Some people may say the food is pricey, but the food is so delicious and the s3rving amount justifies the price. I highly recommend this place, especially if you want steak better than Texas Roadhouse. hah hah

Katina Rusch
5

This place had a great atmosphere and the food was great. We went on a Saturday and I had the ribs. BEST RIBS EVER! This place is pretty pricey but if you are going for a special occasion, order one of the specials, and like a meal worth your money then this place definitely is one you want to try. Remember: you get what you pay for. We went in a group and had to make a reservation.

Mara E
5

Rebecca took care of our table, she is super attentive, polite and kind. She made sure that our plates were at our satisfaction. We enjoyed dinning at Wish. We recommend this place, you won’t be disappointed. We had some delicious calamari, ribs, roasted cauliflower, chopped salad. Everything was well prepared and delicious.

Gavin
5

The food was great! What was great: truffle fries, Picanha with chimichurri aioli (butchers cut), cheese curds. What needs improvement: The roasted vegetables with maple glaze - needed to be roasted a little longer and it could have used a bit more glaze. The crab mushrooms had a watery taste, but had good flavor nonetheless. Our waiter, Kyle, is a great personality. Shoutout to that man. Will be coming back

Location

  • Wish Steakhouse
    Wish Steakhouse
    5006 E Jelinek Ave, Weston, WI 54476, United States Hotline: +1 715-298-2903

Nestled in the heart of Weston, Wisconsin, Wish Steakhouse offers an exceptional dining experience for steak lovers and food aficionados alike. This steakhouse strikes a perfect balance between sophisticated ambiance and warm, attentive service, setting the stage for memorable occasions—from intimate date nights to milestone celebrations.

The menu at Wish Steakhouse reads like a lover’s poem to fine dining. The star attractions, of course, are their expertly prepared steaks, including the irresistibly tender Filet Mignon 6oz and the richly marbled Ribeye. Each cut arrives with a flawless char and a melt-in-your-mouth texture, elevating the classic steakhouse experience to new heights. Patrons consistently praise the meals for their precise seasoning and generous portions, making every bite worth savoring.

Beyond steak, the culinary craftsmanship shines in dishes like the Panko Crusted Walleye with Asparagus, boasting a delightful crunch and delicate flavors, or the buttery, garlicky Shrimp Scampi Pasta. The Walleye with Twice Baked Potato further showcases the kitchen’s finesse with fresh, locally inspired ingredients.

Appetizers such as the crispy Calamari and the tender Scallops open the meal with finesse, while the Cesar Salad provides a refreshing balance. Vegetables like Brussels Sprouts round out the plate with thoughtful preparation, highlighting both texture and flavor.

No meal at Wish Steakhouse is complete without indulging in their decadent desserts. The Key Lime Pie offers a perfect blend of tartness and sweetness, creating a refreshing finish, while the Chocolate Cake and Red Velvet Cake deliver rich, velvety satisfaction that rival family heirlooms. For a lighter touch, the White Peach Sorbet refreshes the palate with pure, fruity elegance.

To complement the cuisine, Wish Steakhouse features unique drinks such as the classic Sprecher Root Beer, adding a nostalgic twist, and craft selections like the Raspberry Grapefruit Pilsner to elevate the dining experience.

What truly sets Wish Steakhouse apart is the harmony between impeccable food and genuine hospitality. Reviews repeatedly highlight the staff’s professionalism and heartfelt attention, ensuring timing and service are flawless. Whether it’s a surprise birthday setup with candlelit tables or a seamless flow of courses without delay, the team crafts moments as thoughtfully as the dishes.

In essence, Wish Steakhouse stands out as a culinary gem where quality ingredients, skilled cooking, and attentive service converge. For those seeking authentic, high-quality steaks matched with sophisticated sides and unforgettable desserts—all served in a welcoming environment—this Weston treasure promises a visit worth repeating.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • Credit cards